December 23rd, 1998
Walmart: Roseburg, Oregon
I am running through the aisles like a mad woman, throwing every sparkling item and sports-themed toy into the basket. My heart is pounding, blood is rushing through my veins, my brain continues to echo, “It’s not enough, it’s not enough!” What seem like thousands of other shoppers are all vying for the same shiny toys and stocking stuffers. My normal, joyful demeanor has been replaced by a wicked, conniving, selfish monster who must get all the toys. Christmas is almost here.
A little background for you. In 1998, my son is five. My daughter is eighteen months. My husband and I have done our best to provide them with everything his salary as a grocery store clerk could. I took on a job as a part-time waitress to get some extra Christmas money and we were planning our first ever vacation without kids over the New Year. I was feeling incredible mom-guilt over going away, so I knew I had to make this Christmas the best ever.
My husband and I came from very modest homes growing up. Neither of our families had much money, but the one thing they did have in common were pretty fantastic Christmases. His mom would make sure the presents were stacked far and wide under the tree. My mom would try her best to make sure we got exactly what we wanted, even if it meant we had to skip on paying a light bill. So you understand, we had tradition to uphold.
Here I was, in the middle of Walmart, pending an anxiety attack, when I looked at my husband and shouted, “We don’t have the stocking stuffers!!” This was followed by tears and my worth as a mother quickly rushing down the emotional toilet in my heart. I grabbed my basket, woman-on-a-mission-style and proceeded to knock other baskets out of the way, as I barreled down the aisles looking for the magical items which would automatically increase my value as both a mother and a human being. My husband, trying to catch up with me, is saying something along the lines of, “slow down, this is ridiculous”. I am tossing baseball cards and a little, glitter-filled baton with streamers on the end, into the cart. Out loud, I repeat what the voice in my head has been saying, “It’s not enough”, as I try to wipe away the tears and shame that stain my face. My husband puts his arm around me and says, “Yes, it is.” I know he is right, but it still feels so wrong.
We go through the check out and I am scanning for the magic items to put in their stocking to fill the void in my soul. Princess chap stick, a baseball key chain, a mini flash light, gum; anything to soothe the ache of contrition within me. In the parking lot, I feel like a failure and ask my husband if we can go to Fred Meyer to see if they have anything else, he says, “no”. I brood.
That night we are lying in bed, talking. “Ali, this has to stop” he says. I know what he is saying is true, but how can it stop? How can I escape this remorse I feel at letting down my kids on this incredibly important day where I prove how much I love them?
He says, “We still have a lot of years to do this, and I can’t deal with this every Christmas”
I ask, “What do we do?”
His response, “Not this”
That Christmas, as the living room was full of wrapping paper and toys, and we were starting clean up, my sweet daughter asked, “more?” Instead of the intense infusion of guilt I expected to come, it was a feeling of sadness.
I had created this.
I had caused this sweet, tiny, beautiful human to want more instead of being content and grateful.
That was the moment I knew things had to change.
And thus began my journey into how to improve Christmas for us. I began to really listen to Christmas carols; love, joy, peace, ‘most wonderful time of the year’, and all that. I am a Christian, so I know this is not only a holiday, but a Holy Day, meant to celebrate our Savior’s birth. It occurred to me, after reading the Christmas Story for the thousandth time that there was a clue in that story. Jesus, as an infant, received only three gifts from the wise men who honored him. Why couldn’t we do that? What would that look like? I mean, Jesus got three, and my kids were certainly not more deserving than He!
I told my husband my plan and he looked at me with his sideways glance and asked if I was serious. I told him I was and I asked him to hold me to it the following year. Around October, he reminded me of my commitment and I balked at the mention of it.
Could I really do this?
So we started talking about it- what should it be? Do we put boundaries on it? Confine it to a specific dollar amount? The kids were so different, how could it be equitable? If we give them the first three things on their list, what about things they need?
After many discussions we came up with the following guidelines. They would receive:
- Something they want
- This was basically the thing they really wanted, a video game, new doll, etc.
- Something they need
- This usually became something like a new baseball glove for our son, dance shoes for our daughter, etc.
- An Experience (preferably with family)
- This could be movie tickets, theme park, a sports event, or a play.
- We also did a stocking which had small things in it
Incredibly, we stuck with it. We let the kids know ahead of time what we were doing. They were young enough to not be disappointed, and knowing how many were coming kept them from expecting more. I was also limited to three items for each so I had to think long and hard. Rarely did my shopping go into December and I never had another ‘Walmart Breakdown’. Christmas became easy after that. In fact, one year we were so broke we didn’t do actual presents- we actually did good deeds for one another, and they were totally on board!
I texted both of my children today and asked, “Now that you are grown, how do you feel about the ‘Three-Gift-Rule”. My son replied, “I liked it, because they were generally really good gifts”. My daughter said, “I liked it. I liked that we always knew the number so we weren’t disappointed like kids who were like, ‘my parents only got me eight presents’”.
I can’t tell you what to do as a young parent, but I can give you this sage advice; don’t give your kids so much that you become the “Christmas Monster” because you spent all your money on presents, and still feel like it is not enough.
Set boundaries, set reasonable expectations, and know that your kids will be better off for it. So will you!
It’s good to know that I didn’t ruin their childhoods by restricting the number of Christmas gifts they received. Instead, I did that by attending every one of their high school dances as a chaperone… (true story)